Vegan Peanut Butter Pudding: Add 1/3 cup of creamy peanut butter to the other ingredients in step one and stir very well with a whisk. Cool; times do not include refrigeration time. I love peanut butter cookies. Reese’s Peanut Butter Pudding Cookies are one of those recipes you’ve just got to try. + chilling . Tip – brown sugar taste great in the peanut butter pudding! Next Recipe . Peanut Butter Pudding "For a creamy, comforting dessert, this smooth pudding can't be beat," assures Edna Hoffman of Hebron, Indiana. Print; Total Time. Rate; Comment; Save; Share. Rate; Comment; Save; Print; Next Recipe . Follow the remainder of the steps the same. Gradually add milk and cook over medium heat until thick and bubbling. (It will be a little clumpy until it warms up, then it will dissolve completely. 4 servings Read Next. Prep: 15 min. Your Low-Calorie Meal Plan for August. Remove from heat, add 1 cup peanut butter and 2 teaspoons vanilla. Test Kitchen Approved; 2 reviews ; Recommended. Makes. Stir constantly. Peanut Butter Pudding: Mix sugar, cornstarch and salt.